
You got a new job. Or you fell in love with a bigger house. Or you just couldn't bear to give up that 3% mortgage rate from a few years ago (we don't blame you). So instead of selling your old home, you're converting your primary residence into a rental property.
Smart move, potentially. But here's what most people don't realize: the day your home becomes a rental is a tax event. Mess up the paperwork, and you could lose your depreciation deductions entirely.
Here's how to convert a primary residence to a rental property without losing your deductions.
A cautionary tale from Tax Court
In Smith v. Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2025-24), a taxpayer converted his former home into a rental and claimed depreciation. When the IRS asked him to prove his depreciable basis, he couldn't. No reliable record of what the property cost. No credible evidence of what it was worth when he converted it. Just his own estimate, which the court essentially called a "guesstimate."
Result: zero depreciation. Not reduced. Zero.
The lesson is simple: basis drives depreciation, and basis has to be proven.
The "lesser-of" rule when you convert a primary residence to a rental
When a home changes from personal use to rental use, your depreciable basis for the building is the lower of:
- Your adjusted basis: what you paid, plus improvements, minus certain adjustments, or
- The fair market value on the date of conversion.
Why the lower number? The IRS won't let you depreciate appreciation that happened while you lived there.
Examples:
- Bought for $300,000, worth $450,000 at conversion: depreciate based on $300,000 (minus land).
- Bought for $300,000, worth $250,000 at conversion: depreciate based on $250,000 (minus land).
In much of South Florida, where home values have climbed a lot over the past several years, your basis is usually your original cost plus improvements. Which means you need to be able to prove both.
What to keep (and what doesn't count)
For your adjusted basis:
- Your closing statement from the original purchase
- Receipts and invoices for improvements (new roof, kitchen remodel, impact windows, pool)
- Records of any casualty losses or insurance reimbursements
For fair market value at conversion:
- A licensed appraisal dated close to the conversion (the gold standard)
- A written broker price opinion or comparative market analysis with comps
- County assessor data can help, but assessed value isn't the same as market value
What doesn't count: a Zillow screenshot. Sorry, Zestimate.
A smart conversion checklist
- Get a valuation at the time you convert.
- Build a basis schedule with purchase price, improvements, and land allocation.
- Document the date it became available for rent: listing records, lease, emails with property managers.
- Time big renovations carefully. Work done after the home is placed in service as a rental is generally depreciable as a rental improvement.
- Consider cost segregation. Even a converted home can benefit, especially with 100% bonus depreciation on qualifying property acquired after January 19, 2025. (Note: property you acquired earlier as a residence may not qualify for 100% bonus, even if converted later, so talk to us about the options.)
- Keep everything for as long as you own the property, plus several years after you sell.
Have a question about your own situation? Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors offer a free consultation. Book a free consultation or call 561-973-8448.
Two Florida-specific things to know
1. You'll lose your homestead exemption. In Florida, your homestead exemption and the Save Our Homes cap only apply to your permanent residence. Once the home becomes a rental, it loses both, and the property tax bill can jump significantly when it's reassessed at market value (subject to the 10% non-homestead cap after that). Build that into your rental numbers. Also notify the county property appraiser. Keeping a homestead exemption on a home you no longer live in can lead to back taxes, penalties, and interest.
2. Watch the Section 121 clock. If you sell a home you lived in for at least two of the last five years, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 if married) from tax. After you convert to a rental, that clock keeps ticking. Wait more than three years to sell, and you may lose the exclusion. Also, depreciation you took (or could have taken) while it was a rental isn't covered by the exclusion and is taxed when you sell.
Why people convert, and when it makes sense
- Keeping a low mortgage rate
- Avoiding a sale in a high-income year
- A temporary job relocation with plans to return
- Long-term appreciation and building a rental portfolio
All great reasons. Just treat the conversion like you're buying a business asset, because, for tax purposes, you are.
Converting a primary residence to a rental can be a smart wealth-building move. Just document it like the business decision it is.
Let us set up your conversion the right way
Atlantic Finance is a virtual, cloud-based team of accountants, enrolled agents (EAs), and tax advisors that got its start in the West Palm Beach area. We help homeowners across South Florida and nationwide convert residences into rentals with a documented basis, the right depreciation setup, and a plan for property taxes and a future sale. Book a virtual consultation. Leave the Zestimate at the door.
How Atlantic Finance can help: our accountants, enrolled agents (EAs) and tax advisors provide tax advisory and year-round tax planning, individual and business tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, and fractional controller services. We're a virtual firm rooted in West Palm Beach, serving clients across South Florida and nationwide.
This article is for general information only and is not tax advice for your specific situation.
Talk to a tax pro about your situation
Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors help individuals and businesses across South Florida and nationwide with tax planning, tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll and fractional controller services.

