
Quick question. Have you ever "rounded up" your business miles at tax time? Built a mileage log in March from memory, Google Maps, and vibes?
If so, please keep reading. Gently. We're not mad. But the IRS might be.
The Tax Court keeps disallowing vehicle deductions for one simple reason: people can't prove them. In a 2025 case, Khan v. Commissioner (T.C. Summary Op. 2025-5), a small business couple lost their vehicle and travel deductions because their records were more creative writing than recordkeeping. Reconstructed spreadsheets and general explanations didn't cut it.
Here's what the rules actually require, and how to stay on the right side of them.
Here are the IRS mileage log requirements and how to stay on the right side of them.
The mileage log requirements: "strict substantiation" means strict
Most business expenses just need reasonable records. But vehicles, travel, and certain other expenses fall under IRC Section 274(d), which requires strict substantiation. For each business use, you need to record:
- Date of the trip
- Where you went
- Business purpose of the trip
- Miles driven (or the amount spent)
And it has to be contemporaneous, meaning recorded at or near the time, not rebuilt at year-end. If it isn't written down (or tracked in an app) when it happens, it basically doesn't exist for tax purposes.
"But the court can estimate it, right?"
Ah, the Cohan rule. It comes from a 1930 case involving Broadway legend George M. Cohan, and it lets courts estimate some deductions when a taxpayer clearly had the expense but lacks perfect records.
Here's the catch: Cohan doesn't apply to Section 274(d) expenses. Congress specifically said vehicles and travel need real proof. So the court can estimate your office supplies. It can't estimate your miles. "But we obviously drove for business" gets the response "Great, show us the log."
Your odometer is a witness
Even a perfect mileage app can be challenged if it doesn't match reality. IRS examiners are trained to check total miles against outside records like:
- Oil change receipts and stickers
- Repair and service invoices
- Dealer maintenance records
- Vehicle inspection or registration records
Snap a photo of your odometer on January 1 and December 31. It takes five seconds and can save a deduction.
The shortcut: a representative period
The IRS knows logging every trip for 365 days is a pain. IRS Publication 463 allows a sample period, such as a representative month or quarter, to establish your business-use percentage, if you can show it's typical of the whole year.
Two conditions:
- The sample log must still be detailed and accurate.
- Nothing major can change during the year (new clients, new routes, a big change in workload).
If your driving is consistent, this can be a lifesaver. If your business changed in June, it probably won't hold up.
Why landlords should care too
Rental property owners drive a lot: checking on properties, meeting contractors, picking up supplies, showing units, visiting the hardware store for the fourth time in one week. Those miles can be deductible, but the same strict rules apply.
Also, if you're tracking material participation for the short-term rental loophole or real estate professional status, your mileage log can double as evidence of your hours. Just be careful: courts have pushed back on counting long drives to a rental as participation time.
Have a question about your own situation? Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors offer a free consultation. Book a free consultation or call 561-973-8448.
Mixed-use vehicles mean mixed risk
Using one car for business and personal driving is normal. But the more personal use is mixed in, the more important a clean log becomes. If your business use drops to 50% or less, you can also lose accelerated depreciation (including Section 179 and bonus depreciation) on the vehicle, and some of what you already took could be recaptured.
S corporation owners: use an accountable plan
If you own an S corporation and you're an employee of it, you generally can't deduct unreimbursed business expenses on your personal return. That deduction disappeared for employees in 2018 and hasn't come back.
The solution is an accountable plan. Your S corp reimburses you for business mileage (often at the IRS standard mileage rate, which was 70 cents per mile for 2025) based on your log. The reimbursement is tax-free to you, and the deduction lands on the business return. Clean, compliant, and defensible, as long as you have the log.
Easy ways to stay compliant
- Use a mileage tracking app that records trips automatically, then tag business purpose.
- Add purpose notes right away ("Met contractor at Lake Worth rental," not "work").
- Take odometer photos at the start and end of each year.
- Keep service records.
- S corp owners: submit monthly reimbursement reports under an accountable plan.
Meeting the mileage log requirements takes about 30 seconds a trip with a good app. Losing the deduction takes a lot longer to recover from.
Let us keep your deductions intact
Atlantic Finance is a virtual, cloud-based team of accountants, enrolled agents (EAs), and tax advisors that got its start in the West Palm Beach area. We help small business owners, S corporation shareholders, and landlords across South Florida and nationwide set up accountable plans, clean up their recordkeeping, and claim vehicle deductions that hold up. Book a virtual consultation. No napkin logs, please.
How Atlantic Finance can help: our accountants, enrolled agents (EAs) and tax advisors provide tax advisory and year-round tax planning, individual and business tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, and fractional controller services. We're a virtual firm rooted in West Palm Beach, serving clients across South Florida and nationwide.
This article is for general information only and is not tax advice for your specific situation.
Talk to a tax pro about your situation
Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors help individuals and businesses across South Florida and nationwide with tax planning, tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll and fractional controller services.

