
Florida homeowners know two universal truths: the kitchen is always "due for an update," and the HOA will have opinions about it.
If that kitchen is in your short-term rental, though, the remodel might come with a bonus: a big first-year tax deduction. Let's talk about qualified improvement property (QIP), how to choose between bonus depreciation and Section 179, and why turning your Airbnb into your personal beach house right after a big write-off can be a spicy move.
Step zero: clear the passive loss rules first
Every rental tax strategy starts with one question: can you actually use the loss? If your modified AGI is over $150,000, rental losses are generally passive and get suspended unless:
- You qualify for real estate professional status, or
- You qualify for the short-term rental loophole (average stay of seven days or less, plus material participation), or
- You have passive income from other rentals or investments to absorb the loss.
Once that's settled, the depreciation strategies below can do their thing.
What is qualified improvement property?
QIP is an interior, non-structural improvement to a nonresidential building, made after the building is placed in service. QIP is 15-year property, which means it's eligible for 100% bonus depreciation and, in many cases, Section 179.
Here's the twist that makes it interesting for STR owners: a rental building generally isn't "residential rental property" for depreciation purposes if more than half of its units are used on a transient basis, which in practice usually means average stays of 30 days or less. So many short-term rentals are treated as nonresidential property. That opens the door to QIP treatment for improvements like:
- Kitchen remodels (cabinets, counters, interior finishes)
- Bathroom renovations
- Interior walls, flooring, and lighting upgrades
What doesn't count as QIP
- Enlarging the building (adding square footage)
- Elevators and escalators
- Changes to the internal structural framework
Those costs go back to the 39-year schedule.
Sequence matters
To support the QIP position, the order of operations is important:
- Place the property in service as a short-term rental (furnished, listed, available).
- Get real guest stays on the books to establish its short-term profile.
- Then take it offline temporarily for the renovation.
Good news: taking a rental offline for renovations doesn't take it out of service as long as you intend to rent it again. You can keep deducting operating expenses during the work, and your hours managing the project can count toward material participation.
Bonus depreciation vs. Section 179: which should you use?
Both let you deduct the cost of qualifying property right away. But they behave differently.
| Bonus depreciation | Section 179 | |
|---|---|---|
| Dollar limit | None | Annual cap ($2.5 million under the new law, indexed) |
| Can create a loss? | Yes | Generally limited to business income; can't create a loss at the partnership level |
| Recapture if business use drops to 50% or less | Generally no mid-stream recapture for real property components | Yes, recaptured as ordinary income |
| Elective per asset? | Elected out by class of property | Elected asset by asset |
| State treatment | Many states don't follow it | More states allow it, often with lower limits |
| Lodging property | Generally fine | Normally not allowed for lodging, but transient lodging like hotels (and many STRs) can qualify |
Florida angle: Florida has no personal income tax, so for most individual Florida owners, state decoupling isn't a concern at home. If your rental is in another state, that state's rules may change the best mix.
Have a question about your own situation? Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors offer a free consultation. Book a free consultation or call 561-973-8448.
The spicy one: converting an STR into a second home
Here's the play some investors consider: buy an STR, do a cost segregation study, take a huge bonus depreciation deduction, then convert it to a personal vacation home shortly after.
Can it work? Sometimes. It depends heavily on timing and facts, and on how an IRS examiner would view your intent.
How the recapture rules work:
- Section 179 can be recaptured as ordinary income the moment business use drops to 50% or less. That could happen the year you convert.
- Bonus depreciation on rental property components generally isn't recaptured just because you convert. Instead, it's recaptured when you sell, unless you do a 1031 exchange.
The risk spectrum, from tame to aggressive:
- STR to long-term or mid-term rental: relatively tame
- STR to a vacation home with some rental use: moderate
- STR to second home or primary residence after a few years: higher
- Big cost segregation in December, personal use starting in January: the most aggressive, and the easiest for the IRS to challenge
Practical takeaway: if you think you'll eventually use the property personally, lean toward bonus depreciation over Section 179, keep the property genuinely in business use for a meaningful period, and document your business purpose.
A few bonus tips
- Maintenance days don't count as personal-use days. If you spend substantially all of a day doing real repairs, it generally doesn't count as personal use under the vacation home rules.
- HVAC and roofs on nonresidential property aren't QIP, but Section 179 has a specific carve-out that can apply to roofs, HVAC, fire protection, and security systems.
- Keep receipts and before-and-after photos of every renovation.
If you're planning a remodel, confirm the qualified improvement property treatment before the contractor starts, not after.
Planning a remodel? Call us before the contractor.
Atlantic Finance is a virtual, cloud-based team of accountants, enrolled agents (EAs), and tax advisors that got its start in the West Palm Beach area. We help short-term rental owners across Florida and nationwide time renovations, choose between bonus depreciation and Section 179, and plan for future personal use without stepping on a recapture landmine. Book a virtual consultation. The HOA is your problem, though.
How Atlantic Finance can help: our accountants, enrolled agents (EAs) and tax advisors provide tax advisory and year-round tax planning, individual and business tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, and fractional controller services. We're a virtual firm rooted in West Palm Beach, serving clients across South Florida and nationwide.
This article is for general information only and is not tax advice for your specific situation.
Talk to a tax pro about your situation
Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors help individuals and businesses across South Florida and nationwide with tax planning, tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll and fractional controller services.

