Business Tax

The Goldilocks Guide to S Corp Reasonable Salary: Not Too High, Not Too Low

By the Accountants, EAs & Tax Advisors at Atlantic Finance

October 16, 2026
The Goldilocks Guide to S Corp Reasonable Salary: Not Too High, Not Too Low

Remember Goldilocks? One bowl of porridge too hot, one too cold, one just right. That's basically the S corp reasonable compensation problem.

Pay yourself too much, and you overpay payroll taxes. Pay yourself too little, and you're inviting the IRS to reclassify your distributions as wages, with back taxes, penalties, and interest. You want "just right." Here's how to find it.

Why the IRS cares

When you own an S corporation and work in it, your profits can come out two ways:

  • Salary (W-2 wages): subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes, a combined 15.3% up to the Social Security wage base, and 2.9% (plus 0.9% for high earners) above it.
  • Distributions: no payroll taxes.

That's the whole point of the S corp. But it's also why the IRS insists you pay yourself a reasonable salary first. Otherwise, everyone would pay themselves $1 and take the rest as distributions.

What does "reasonable" mean for S corp reasonable compensation?

There's no formula in the tax code. Courts and the IRS look at facts and circumstances, including:

  • Your training and experience
  • Your duties and responsibilities
  • Time and effort devoted to the business
  • What comparable businesses pay for similar services
  • What you'd pay someone else to do your job
  • The company's revenue, profits, and dividend history
  • How salary compares to distributions

A common question is whether there's a "60/40 rule" (60% salary, 40% distributions). There isn't. It's a myth. Your salary should be based on the value of the work you do, not a fixed ratio.

Three ways to calculate it

1. The cost approach ("many hats")

The most common approach for small S corps. List every role you play and how much time you spend in each:

Role Share of time Market wage for that role
Licensed professional or technician 60% High
Sales and business development 15% Moderate to high
Management 10% Moderate to high
Bookkeeping and admin 10% Lower
Cleaning and errands 5% Lower

Multiply each by the local market wage and add them up. That's a defensible starting point.

2. The market approach

What do similar companies pay someone in your position? Industry compensation surveys and job data help here.

3. The income approach

What return would a hypothetical outside investor expect from the business? The rest of the profit is attributed to your work. More common for larger businesses.

Have a question about your own situation? Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors offer a free consultation. Book a free consultation or call 561-973-8448.

Document, document, document

A written compensation analysis does two things:

  1. Helps you pick a sensible number.
  2. Gives you evidence if the IRS ever asks why you chose it.

Many advisors use compensation analysis software that walks through your location, hours, tasks, and skill level and produces a report. Whatever you use, be honest with the inputs. Inflating or deflating your hours and skills defeats the purpose.

Other things to consider

  • Retirement contributions: solo 401(k) employer contributions are based on W-2 wages. A very low salary limits how much you can contribute.
  • QBI deduction: salary reduces qualified business income, but the W-2 wage limit can matter at higher incomes. There's a balance.
  • Low-profit years: if the business barely makes money, a lower salary may be reasonable. You can't pay what you don't have.
  • Revisit annually: as your role and profits change, your salary should too.

S corp reasonable compensation isn't a one-time decision. Review it every year as your business changes.

Find your "just right"

Atlantic Finance is a virtual, cloud-based team of accountants, enrolled agents (EAs), and tax advisors that got its start in the West Palm Beach area. We help S corporation owners across South Florida and nationwide set reasonable compensation, document it properly, run payroll, and balance salary, distributions, and retirement contributions. Book a virtual consultation. No bears involved.

How Atlantic Finance can help: our accountants, enrolled agents (EAs) and tax advisors provide tax advisory and year-round tax planning, individual and business tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, and fractional controller services. We're a virtual firm rooted in West Palm Beach, serving clients across South Florida and nationwide.

This article is for general information only and is not tax advice for your specific situation.

Talk to a tax pro about your situation

Our accountants, EAs and tax advisors help individuals and businesses across South Florida and nationwide with tax planning, tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll and fractional controller services.

Contact Us NowCall